When Efficiency Costs Us Expertise
The Monday-Morning Test
Imagine opening an email on Monday morning informing you that your practice has been selected for an in-network audit. At first, you are not particularly concerned. Your claims are submitted electronically. Payments are posted automatically. Contracted fees live in your software. Eligibility is verified digitally. You invested in technology specifically to make these processes faster, cleaner, and more accurate.
Then the questions begin. A fee schedule was mapped incorrectly. A contractual adjustment was applied improperly. The same error appears again. And again. No employee intentionally made the mistake. In fact, perhaps no employee made the mistake at all. The system did exactly what it had been configured, instructed, or trained to do.
So now comes the question I think dentistry needs to ask before our race toward instant becomes a race toward replacement: Who was responsible for knowing it was wrong?
The Promise of Instant
There is a word being sold aggressively in dentistry right now: instant. Instant insurance verification. Instant claim processing. Instant payment posting. Instant eligibility. Instant answers. I understand the appeal. I have spent much of my career in dental operations and revenue cycle management, and I know how exhausting the administrative side of dentistry can become.
I have watched talented team members spend hours navigating payer portals, interpreting benefits, correcting claims, reconciling payments, researching fee schedules, and explaining why yesterday's benefit information does not seem to match today’s explanation of benefits. If technology can remove repetitive work, identify patterns we miss, and give our teams better tools, I am interested.
What concerns me is not AI. It is the assumption that because technology can perform a task, the human behind that task has become unnecessary, dispensable even. Somewhere between using technology and replacing people with it, we risk removing the very people who learned how to recognize when the answer is wrong.
Discernment Cannot Be Downloaded
Insurance verification has never been simply retrieving a number. Neither has payment posting, claim submission, fee schedule management, or revenue cycle management. The best people I have worked with develop something difficult to quantify on a dashboard: discernment.
They know when a benefit breakdown does not make sense. They recognize when a fee looks wrong. They notice when an allowed amount does not resemble the contracted fee they have seen hundreds of times before. They understand that “covered” does not always mean payable in the circumstances sitting in front of them. That knowledge was developed through repetition, mistakes, questions, mentorship, and experience.
One of the most dangerous errors in revenue cycle management is not the obvious one. It is the error that looks reasonable. A payment posts. The account balances. The claim closes. Nothing flashes red. Everyone moves on. But if the wrong fee schedule was used or an adjustment was applied incorrectly, a small error can quietly repeat across hundreds of transactions. Efficiency can become a very efficient way to be wrong.
The Expertise Gap
We talk frequently about whether AI will eliminate jobs. I think that may be the smaller question. I am more concerned about whether it will eliminate the experiences that create experts.
Today’s revenue-cycle leader did not begin her career knowing how to identify a contractual discrepancy buried in an EOB. She learned because she posted payments, questioned adjustments, researched denials, called payers, made mistakes, and had someone explain why something did not add up. Eventually, repetition became recognition, and recognition became judgment.
If AI performs all of the foundational work, where does the next generation develop that judgment? If we automate the bottom rungs of the ladder, how will anyone learn to climb it? Who will know enough to challenge the algorithm, recognize the exception, or train the next person? Technology may remove tasks, but our industry cannot afford for it to remove understanding.
We Can Automate the Task. Not the Accountability.
This is where the conversation becomes uncomfortable. If an employee submits an incorrect claim or posts a payment incorrectly, we can correct it, retrain, examine the workflow, and determine how the mistake occurred. But when an automated system makes the decision, who owns the result? The software company? The practice? The dentist whose name and NPI appear on the claim? The person who clicked approve? The billing company using the technology?
A computer completing the transaction does not make the practice's contracts, documentation requirements, payer policies, patient balances, or financial accountability disappear. We can automate the task. We cannot automate accountability.
Now Sit Across From the Auditor
Imagine being asked why a particular fee was used on hundreds of claims. “That's what the software populated.” Why were these adjustments taken? “That's how the system posted them.” Who verified the configuration? Who noticed the pattern? Who had enough experience to know the output did not make sense? Suddenly, automation is not an answer. It is the beginning of another question.
I am not suggesting that automation automatically creates an audit problem, or that human beings do not make errors. Of course we do. My concern is scale. A human can make a mistake. A system can replicate the same mistake thousands of times without fatigue, hesitation, or the instinct to wonder whether something feels off. That is why human oversight becomes more important as automation becomes more powerful, not less.
This Is Not an Argument Against AI
I use technology. I believe in innovation. I think artificial intelligence will change dentistry in extraordinary ways, and many of those changes will be positive. What I resist is our fascination with replacement.
I want technology that tells an experienced revenue-cycle professional, “Something about these accounts does not match the expected pattern.” I want software that identifies discrepancies before a person could reasonably find them manually. I want automation handling repetitive keystrokes so talented people have more time to investigate exceptions, communicate with patients, and solve complex problems.
I want machines doing what machines do beautifully and humans doing what humans do beautifully: questioning, interpreting, connecting, recognizing context, and exercising judgment. That partnership is far more interesting to me than replacement.
Maybe Faster Isn’t the Only Metric
Dentistry needs relief from administrative burden. Teams are exhausted. Practices are controlling overhead. Patients want answers quickly. Doctors want to practice dentistry rather than spend evenings untangling insurance problems. AI can help us do that. But perhaps the goal should not be eliminating humans from the process. Perhaps the goal should be eliminating the parts of the process that prevent humans from doing their best work.
There is enormous value in instant information. There is even greater value in knowing whether that information is right. The future of dentistry does not need fewer intelligent people because we have more intelligent technology. It needs people whose expertise has evolved enough to know when to trust the technology – and when not to.
As we race toward the next platform promising to make another piece of dentistry instantaneous, I hope we leave a chair at the table for the person willing to look at the answer and say, “Wait. Something about this doesn’t make sense.”
Because the question is no longer simply whether AI can do the job. The question is: who are we developing to know when it did not do the job correctly?
About the Author
Helen Sublette, BS, RDA, CDA, COA, CDIPC, MADAA is a dental operations and revenue cycle management leader and Founder/CEO of Coastal Dental Professionals Consulting, Inc. Her career has centered on dental insurance, revenue cycle strategy, operational leadership, and developing the people and systems behind successful practices. She is passionate about advancing technology in dentistry without sacrificing the human judgment, accountability, and expertise necessary to protect practices, patients, and the future of the profession.
Coastal Dental Professionals Consulting, Inc.
Founder & CEO: Helen Sublette, BS, CDA, COA, CDIPC, MADAA
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/helen-sublette
Website: https://coastalcarolinadentalconsulting.com/